The soccer league established its Hall of Fame in 2009 with its first inductees. A plaque hangs in the lobby of Eastchester Town Hall, 40 Mill Road, which lists the members.
| Class of 2009 | |
|---|---|
| Bob Dohrenwend | longtime coach, appointments committee head, commissioner |
| Jerry Fischoff | registrar, club historian, referee, webmaster |
| John DiMarzo | longtime coach, trainer, board member |
| Class of 2010 | |
| Frank D'Onofrio | longtime coach, treasurer, equipment manager, board member |
| Vinny Vetrini | member of original board, longtime coach, referee |
| Class of 2011 | |
| Gerry Mignardi | former president, coach, treasurer |
| Jim Salomone | former president, field liaison, longterm coach |
| Class of 2012 | |
| Michael Pisacreta | member of original board, first league registrar |
| Rick Croiter | first elected vice-president, first rec league Commissioner |
| Jack Langstine | longtime coach, referee director, board member |
| Class of 2013 | |
| Julian DiDonato | commissioner, Vice-president, program innovator |
| Tony Amato | longtime coach, trainer |
| Donald Cerasi | former President, Commissioner, coach |